Description
The Serviceberry begins in a berry patch and ends, several propositions about capitalism later, more or less back in that same patch. The path taken matters more than the conclusion reached — which is itself the book’s first quiet argument. Robin Wall Kimmerer is asking what kind of thinking might count as economic if we stopped pretending economics means only the part you can graph.
The premise fits in one hand. Kimmerer — Potawatomi botanist, MacArthur Fellow, author of Braiding Sweetgrass — takes the serviceberry tree, a North American native that produces sweet purple fruit in early summer, and uses it as the frame for a reflection on gift economies. The tree feeds the birds; the birds carry the seed; the seed becomes more trees that feed more birds. From this loop she draws a model: economies built on reciprocity rather than accumulation, on relationship rather than transaction. She braids in Potawatomi philosophy, anecdotes from rural New York, a conversation with an ecological economist friend, the saga of a community free farm stand stolen one autumn. The whole essay arrives in under two hundred small pages, illustrated, the kind of book you can wrap as a birthday present.
This is where it works best. Kimmerer writes about the natural world with the patience of someone who has actually spent time in it. There is no hurry in the sentences, no nervous reaching for the next idea. The biological account is precise and unshowy. Serviceberries really do depend on a web of mutualism — pollinators above, mycorrhizal networks below, birds carrying seed in their guts to scatter elsewhere — and the book is at its most persuasive when it lets that fact carry most of the weight. Reading her, you feel the metaphor is not a metaphor at all but a description of how things already work.
The trouble starts when the description has to become a prescription. Kimmerer is candid about her own limits. “Because I’m a botanist, my knowledge of economics and finance is about the size of the frilly little cup at the tip of a Juneberry that was once part of the flower,” she writes — a charming sentence that also names the problem. The book wants to do real economic work, to propose gift economies as a structural alternative to extractive capitalism, but it relies almost entirely on anecdote and analogy to get there. A free zucchini stand on a country road, a public library, the Nordic welfare state, a single conversation with an ecological economist, the Buy Nothing movement — these gesture toward something. They do not add up to a mechanism. A reader who picks the book up hungry for some account of how reciprocity might restructure, say, energy markets or housing policy will leave with the same hunger.
She half-acknowledges this. She notes, more than once, that gift economies have historically flourished in small, close-knit communities and that scaling them is a real question. Then she gestures at mutual aid and moves on. The honest move would be either to commit to the local — to argue that smallness is the point, that anything larger is a different conversation — or to stress-test the model against the global problems she invokes. She does neither, and the book is softer for it but also less load-bearing.
There is a quieter problem beneath the biology. The serviceberry “gives” because giving is how it reproduces; the bird eats the fruit, the seed passes through, the seedling sprouts. Kimmerer briefly notes that an evolutionary biologist could read all this as self-interest maximizing under another name, and waves the objection off in a sentence. But the objection is the place where the metaphor’s moral weight comes from. If a tree’s reciprocity is just its reproductive strategy, then “gift” is doing more rhetorical labor than the biology can pay for. The book does not have to resolve this. It could sit with it longer than it does.
Then there is Darren. Kimmerer’s name for the figure of the rapacious capitalist — borrowed, she tells us, from the CEO of ExxonMobil — is sharp and a little funny and slightly out of register with everything else. I kept wanting more of him as I read, not less. The device punctures the otherwise reverent tone, which is part of the appeal. It also reveals a politics the rest of the book isn’t willing to sustain. Naming the enemy makes the gentleness elsewhere look almost like restraint, as though the book is choosing, repeatedly, not to take the swing it could.
What stays, after the argument’s thinner parts are accounted for, is the texture. Late in the book Kimmerer’s father reveals that the family ceremony of pouring out the first cup of coffee to “the gods of Tahawus” — which she had read as ancestral — started as a practical matter of clearing grounds from the spout of a battered camping percolator. “It started out that way, but it became something else.” The whole project is in that line. Meaning is made by repetition into form, and form, given time, becomes belonging. Whether that is enough to build an economy on is the question the book sets down beside the bowl of berries and walks away from.
If you’d like to read the full book in EPUB or MOBI format, feel free to send me an email—I’d be happy to share a free copy with you. Please reach me at: thenovaleaf@gmail.com
Reviews
There are no reviews yet.